Hair Loss Treatment Selector
Find Your Best Treatment
Answer a few questions to get personalized recommendations based on the latest research
Rogaine 5 has been the go-to solution for hair loss for decades. It’s the brand name for 5% minoxidil, a topical treatment approved by the FDA and used by millions. But with so many new options on the market, is it still the best choice? And if it’s not working for you, what else actually delivers results?
How Rogaine 5 Really Works
Rogaine 5 contains 5% minoxidil, a vasodilator that wakes up dormant hair follicles. It doesn’t grow new hair where there’s no follicle - it reactivates ones that have slowed down. Studies show about 65% of men using it daily for 4-6 months see some regrowth, mostly along the crown and hairline. Women using the 5% formula report similar results, though they often need to use it longer before noticing changes.
The catch? You have to keep using it. Stop for even a few weeks, and you’ll start shedding again. That’s because minoxidil doesn’t fix the root cause - usually genetic hair loss (androgenetic alopecia). It just keeps the follicles active while you’re using it.
Top Alternatives to Rogaine 5
If Rogaine isn’t working, or you hate the sticky feeling, the mess, or the daily routine, here are the most proven alternatives.
Finasteride (Propecia)
Finasteride is an oral pill that blocks DHT, the hormone that shrinks hair follicles in genetic hair loss. Unlike minoxidil, it targets the cause, not just the symptom. Clinical trials show 83% of men using finasteride stopped hair loss after one year, and 66% saw visible regrowth.
It’s not topical, so it works systemically. That means it can affect more areas - including the front and temples - where minoxidil often falls short. But it comes with potential side effects: reduced libido, erectile dysfunction, and mood changes in a small percentage of users. These usually go away after stopping, but some report lingering effects (post-finasteride syndrome), though this is rare and debated.
Finasteride isn’t approved for women of childbearing age due to birth defect risks. But post-menopausal women can use it under supervision.
Low-Level Laser Therapy (LLLT) Devices
Devices like the iRestore Laser Cap or Capillus 272 use red light to stimulate follicles. They’re non-invasive, painless, and have no systemic side effects. A 2019 study in the Journal of Clinical and Aesthetic Dermatology found that 74% of users saw improved hair density after 26 weeks of consistent use.
They work best when combined with minoxidil or finasteride. Used alone, results are slower and less dramatic. You need to use them 3-5 times a week for at least 6 months. The upfront cost is high - $300 to $1,000 - but no ongoing fees. Good for people who want a drug-free option.
Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) Injections
PRP uses your own blood. A technician draws a small amount, spins it in a centrifuge to concentrate platelets, then injects it into your scalp. The growth factors in platelets help regenerate tissue and reduce inflammation around follicles.
Studies show PRP can improve hair density and thickness, especially when combined with minoxidil. One 2022 trial found PRP users gained 22% more hairs per cm² after 6 months compared to minoxidil alone. But it’s expensive - £150 to £300 per session - and you need 3-4 sessions initially, then maintenance every 3-6 months. Not covered by the NHS or most insurance plans.
Spironolactone (for Women)
Spironolactone is a prescription pill often used for acne and high blood pressure, but it’s also effective for female pattern hair loss. It blocks androgen receptors, reducing the impact of testosterone on hair follicles.
Women using spironolactone (typically 50-100 mg daily) report slower shedding and noticeable regrowth after 6-12 months. It’s not approved for men because it can cause breast enlargement and other hormonal side effects. It’s also not safe during pregnancy.
Essential Oils and Natural Supplements
Peppermint oil, rosemary oil, and saw palmetto are popular natural alternatives. Rosemary oil, in particular, has shown promise. A 2015 study found it worked as well as 2% minoxidil for hair growth over 6 months, with fewer scalp irritations.
But here’s the truth: these don’t work for everyone. They’re not regulated like drugs, so quality varies wildly. Saw palmetto may help some men by mildly blocking DHT, but studies are small and inconsistent. You’ll need to use them daily for 6+ months and accept that results are unpredictable.
Comparison Table: Rogaine 5 vs Alternatives
| Treatment | How It Works | Time to See Results | Effectiveness | Side Effects | Cost (Monthly) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rogaine 5 (Minoxidil) | Stimulates follicles | 3-6 months | 65% see regrowth | Scalp irritation, initial shedding | £15-£30 |
| Finasteride (Propecia) | Blocks DHT hormone | 3-12 months | 83% stop loss, 66% regrow | Low libido, erectile issues (rare) | £10-£25 |
| LLLT Devices | Red light stimulates cells | 4-8 months | 74% see improvement | None | £10-£20 (amortized) |
| PRP Injections | Growth factors from own blood | 3-6 months | 22% more growth vs minoxidil alone | Mild pain, bruising | £50-£100 |
| Spironolactone (Women) | Blocks androgen receptors | 6-12 months | 60-70% see improvement | Menstrual changes, fatigue | £5-£15 |
| Rosemary Oil | Anti-inflammatory, mild DHT blocker | 6+ months | Comparable to 2% minoxidil | Scalp sensitivity | £5-£10 |
Who Should Choose What?
There’s no one-size-fits-all. Your best option depends on your gender, budget, tolerance for side effects, and how fast you want results.
- If you’re a man and want the strongest, fastest results: finasteride is your best bet. Add minoxidil if you want even more density.
- If you’re a woman with hormonal hair loss: spironolactone or 5% minoxidil are the top choices. Avoid finasteride.
- If you hate pills or chemicals: LLLT devices are safe and effective - just be patient and consistent.
- If you’ve tried everything and still see thinning: PRP can give you that extra boost, especially if you’re in your 30s or 40s.
- If you’re on a tight budget and want something natural: rosemary oil is worth a shot, but don’t expect miracles.
What Doesn’t Work
There’s a lot of noise out there. Don’t waste your money on:
- Hair growth shampoos with biotin or keratin - they don’t penetrate deep enough to affect follicles.
- Scalp micropigmentation - it’s cosmetic, not a treatment. It looks like shaved hair, but doesn’t grow real hair.
- Supplements like biotin - unless you have a severe deficiency (rare), they won’t help hair loss.
- Topical caffeine serums - some early studies show promise, but no long-term data yet.
Combining Treatments for Better Results
The smartest approach isn’t picking one - it’s layering. Most dermatologists recommend combining treatments for maximum effect.
For example:
- Men: Finasteride + Rogaine 5 + LLLT
- Women: Minoxidil 5% + rosemary oil + PRP if budget allows
Studies show that combining minoxidil and finasteride leads to 85-90% of users seeing improvement - far better than either alone. LLLT adds another 10-15% boost in density.
Don’t try everything at once. Start with one, give it 6 months, then add another if needed. Too many products at once can irritate your scalp and make it hard to tell what’s working.
When to See a Doctor
If you’re losing more than 100 hairs a day, noticing bald patches, or your hairline is receding rapidly, see a dermatologist. Hair loss can be a sign of thyroid issues, iron deficiency, or autoimmune conditions like alopecia areata.
They can do a scalp biopsy or blood test to rule out other causes. If it’s just genetic hair loss, they can prescribe finasteride or spironolactone - which you can’t get over the counter in the UK.
Also, if you’ve tried minoxidil for 6 months with no change, it’s time to switch strategies. Not everyone responds to it - and that’s okay. There are other paths.
Is Rogaine 5 better than generic minoxidil?
No. Rogaine 5 is just branded minoxidil. The active ingredient is identical to generic 5% minoxidil solutions sold by pharmacies like Boots or Superdrug. You’re paying for the brand, packaging, and scent. Generic versions cost half as much and work just as well.
Can I use minoxidil and finasteride together?
Yes, and many doctors recommend it. Minoxidil stimulates growth, while finasteride stops the hormone that causes thinning. Together, they work on two different pathways, leading to better results than either alone. Studies show up to 90% of men see improvement with the combo.
Does minoxidil work on a receding hairline?
It can, but less reliably than on the crown. The frontal hairline has fewer active follicles, so results are often slower and less dramatic. For best results on the hairline, combine minoxidil with finasteride or PRP.
How long do I need to use minoxidil?
For as long as you want to keep the results. Minoxidil doesn’t cure hair loss - it manages it. If you stop, you’ll lose the hair you gained within 3-6 months. Most people use it for life, like taking blood pressure medication.
Are there any new hair loss treatments on the horizon?
Yes. JAK inhibitors like ruxolitinib (used for alopecia areata) and topical prostaglandin analogs like bimatoprost are showing promise in trials. Some are already available by prescription in the US. In the UK, they’re still experimental or limited to clinical trials. Don’t expect them to replace minoxidil or finasteride anytime soon.
Final Thoughts
Rogaine 5 is still a solid option - cheap, accessible, and backed by decades of research. But it’s not the only option. Finasteride is more powerful for men. Spironolactone is better for women. LLLT and PRP offer drug-free paths. And rosemary oil? It’s worth trying if you want something gentle.
The key isn’t finding the "best" treatment. It’s finding the one that fits your life, your body, and your goals. Start with one. Stick with it for six months. Track progress with photos. Then adjust. Hair loss isn’t a race - it’s a long-term project. And you have more control than you think.
